Join the 3,000 people getting fresh weekly insights about proptech and the real estate industry.

    Key takeaways


    • This Poplar Propcast episode explores the intricate world of rental scams, dissecting their psychology, stating consequences for consumers and businesses, and offering practical strategies to safeguard against scams.
    • The blog highlights the “False Listing Scam,” revealing how scammers exploit vulnerable renters seeking affordable housing, often targeting single-family rentals.
    • The real estate industry actively battles rental fraud by introducing friction through technological solutions, informative messaging, and innovative measures.


    Step into the realm of property insights with a new episode of the Poplar Propcast, hosted by Justin Lieberknecht, VP of Marketing at Poplar Homes. In this installment, the spotlight is on a pressing issue that affects both tenants and property owners – rental scams.

    With Justin as your guide, this episode delves into the intricate world of rental scams. From dissecting the psychology that makes these scams work to unraveling their consequences on consumers and businesses, this episode offers a comprehensive view of the landscape. Whether you’re a vigilant property manager, a cautious resident, or an astute owner, tune in to discover practical strategies to shield yourself against rental scams.



    False listing scam: A twisted game of deception


    In the realm of real estate, dreams can become nightmares for the vulnerable, as revealed by Justin in the “Fraudcast” episode of the Poplar Propcast, exposing the “False Listing Scam.” The FBI’s investigations indicate that victims are often “supremely embarrassed,” making it an under-reported issue. This sophisticated scam preys on reasonable people’s vulnerabilities, exploiting their pursuit of better housing.

    Single-family rentals are the prime target, as Justin notes. Families in tight spots, like a “two-parent household with two kids in a two-bedroom apartment,” are particularly susceptible. The scam lures victims with ads promising a “three-bedroom, two-bath for $1,200 a month,” exploiting their desires. The scammers play mind games, invoking faith or neatness to appear genuine.

    Once entrapped, victims wire money and move in, only to be met with a rude awakening when the true property owner surfaces. The choices are grim: “apply and clear, or move out, or get evicted,” Justin outlines. This ordeal leaves victims emotionally drained and financially crippled, as they lose their savings to non-refundable methods like Zelle or cashier’s checks.


    Recommended: The Housing Theory of Everything: A conversation with John Myers



    Agentless showings and the ongoing battle against rental fraud


    In the fast-paced world of real estate, convenience often clashes with caution. Justin sheds light on the challenges posed by agentless showings and the relentless battle against rental fraud.

    In the quest for the perfect rental, two online giants, Craigslist and Facebook, emerge as notorious breeding grounds for fraudulent listings. Justin underscores that these platforms lack moderation and verification processes, creating “unpoliced marketplaces.” Even Craigslist’s practice of charging for housing posts in some markets has yet to stem the tide of deception. Victims often encounter bait-and-switch tactics, as Justin reveals, where enticing offers turn into demands for fees to access preferred properties.

    Zillow, a powerhouse in the listing domain, also faced a major hurdle due to fraudulent listings as scammers exploited minute address variations, duping renters into wiring money for properties that weren’t actually available. However, Zillow has since made significant strides in curbing this menace.

    As Justin’s narrative spans nearly a decade, it’s clear that the real estate industry has been engaged in a constant battle against fraudulent practices. National companies like First Key Invitation Homes, American Homes for Rent, and Tricon Residential have collaborated through the National Rental Home Council to share best practices and combat this issue. This united effort reflects the industry’s commitment to prevent individuals from falling prey to such scams.

    Justin sheds light on the evolution of strategies against rental fraud. Initially, companies took a hands-on approach, actively identifying and dismantling fraudulent postings across various platforms. This involved matching victim-reported listings with legitimate ones and reporting fraudulent cases. Yet, this process proved labor-intensive.

    Then, agentless showings emerged, or self-guided tours made available for interested renters. Justin explains that this concept was introduced to offer potential renters greater flexibility in scheduling tours. However, debates ensued regarding its implications. The industry grappled with whether agentless showings, which eliminate the need for on-site agents, might compromise security and exacerbate the risk of fraud.

    Justin clarifies that the industry’s approach wasn’t rooted in the absence of agents but rather in enhancing convenience for potential renters. The aim was to enable them to tour properties at their convenience. Implementing mandatory agent presence would not only inconvenience renters but also increase costs, potentially passed on to tenants.



    Empowering renters through awareness and innovation


    Justin shares his insights into the evolving strategies of both the industry and scammers as well as the measures taken to protect potential renters and the tactics scammers employ. A complex web of awareness and innovation emerges.

    Justin emphasizes the industry’s commitment to thwart scams by introducing “friction” into the rental process. Employing technological solutions and informative messaging, professionals strive to ensure that renters question the legitimacy of listings. Adaptation is key, as scammers adjust their methods in response. By impersonating property managers and manipulating listings, scammers exploit those seeking affordable housing.

    Now, leveraging FBI data, Justin underscores the alarming rise of rental fraud—up by 64% in 2021. The need for collective action and vigilance becomes evident in the face of these escalating threats.

    But he also envisions a landscape of enhanced safety measures, from cameras to two-way speakers and technology-driven innovations to create barriers against scammers.


    Up next: Building your dream home with DEN (a Propcast episode)



    Concluding thoughts


    In this Propcast episode, Justin’s comprehensive insights shed light on the persistent challenges posed by rental fraud, underlining the importance of industry-wide collaboration and innovative solutions. The evolving strategies of both professionals and scammers reflect an ongoing battle to safeguard the dreams of prospective renters.

    Amid the ever-changing landscape, the industry’s commitment to inserting “friction” and employing technology-driven measures stands as a testament to its dedication. By fostering awareness, empathy, and resilience, professionals strive to create a safer rental environment, ensuring that renters find homes that are not only authentic but also nurturing spaces for their aspirations.




    Learn the ROI on property management using our ROI calculator